US blogger outreach in consumer absolutely depends on Mommy Bloggers. At my last job, pretty much every campaign I was a part of involved moms in some way. Clients wanted to ‘tap in’ to the Mommy blogosphere because they constantly heard how valuabe they all are – and giving a couple hundred samples of product out to influential household decision makers is just a drop in the bucket for their budgets.
Last summer, assuming my new job would now be all about Mummies, I started reading a lot more Mummy blogs, trying to get acclimated to the Mommy/Mummy differences. I found a fair amount (no where near as many as in America), but what I did not find was any evidence of PR involvement. 
I thought this was a fantastic opportunity. After all, how amazing would it be to be at the forefront of this vast, new “undiscovered” online consumer market in the UK?
Going a bit farther back, I remember when I was interviewing in London, someone asking me why the hell any bloggers – even Mums – would care about a granola bar. I replied, “Why wouldn’t they? If someone legitimate on the street came up to you with a free sample of something, you’d take it, right? And if it was really good you might tell someone to try it, yes?”
That was always my thought about Mommy Bloggers. Of course, they’ll try a granola bar or a DVD for the kids or a candle. Why not? People like free stuff! I assumed this thought process would work for the UK as well.
Yeah, not so much… But not necessarily because they don’t like free stuff. It really comes down to a the fundamental differences in Mommies and Mummies, which I see as the following:
- Privacy – Us Yanks have a tendency to talk way too much about ourselves to anyone who will listen. Yank Moms (from my experience) tend to talk an awful lot about their kids. I haven’t run into the same thing here at all. In fact, a lot of the Mummy blogs I’ve run into are written by American Moms living in the UK.
- Community – Yes, there is a Mummy blogging community, but it’s no where near as vast or as interactive. It’s more about Mums getting the information they need online and getting out, which brings me to…
- Need – What seems to be more popular and – dare I say – useful to UK mums are the more traditional advice-giving sites like Mums Net and Net Mums. (Really clever names, by the way…)
So does PR involvement with Mums even stand a chance? It depends.
The limited outreach that I’ve done with Mums suggests that it doesn’t, but in all fairness I haven’t had any campaigns that are a perfect fit for the Mummy market (I haven’t so much as touched a product for review in five months). But I also haven’t really seen other agencies work with them either. This could mean that either there really *is* a huge opportunity out there or it could mean that this sort of online PR simply won’t work. Or, from a truly business perspective it could mean that because there isn’t as big of an audience and/or community, it’s simply not worth the hours.
My thought is that it’s a little of everything. Even if Mummy blogging takes off and UK PR gets in on the game, it won’t be and can’t be done in the same fashion as in America. I’m not holding my breath though.
*Mummy photo from Mego Museum
10 January, 2009 at 7:30 pm
Interesting post Melanie – We’ve not had a relevant project to talk to Mums about, so it’s hard for me to comment, but with your US experience, you’re in a much better position to judge than anyone else, so I think you’re probably right.
I do think there’s still real potential for the right sort of project to work really well in this space, but probably through online communities (two of which you mention) rather than blogs.
11 January, 2009 at 2:40 pm
It’s about two years behind…
I get about five or six PR enqueries a week, which I agree is way behind my US counterparts.
Also — there are lots of “British” mummy bloggers too, this list is just a start http://tinyurl.com/5ueo9t
28 January, 2009 at 7:21 am
Hi – I’m a Mummy blogger and I keep professional and domestic blogging vastly separate. When it comes to all of this Web2.0/3.0 stuff much of it all is still in the Make-it-up-as-you-go-along domain -so what counts today, may not necessarily tomorrow.
In my experience, I’ve found the US and Europe are oceans apart in the social media world. And this is the same with European and American media as well. There are lots of differences in how PR works in the territories too. But I digress, back to the bloggery stuff. The US is comfortable with the marketing mix spilling into this arena, whereas in Europe, people seem to prefer a less marketing-led approach. I’ve worked with bloggers in Europe and found them a unique bunch of people, and different in every country. Using traditional PR tools such as product placement is perhaps not the way to engage with them as generally they don’t want to play ball (unless they are professional bloggers or a network of independent bloggers). Best keep in mind that ‘consumer generated’ is all about listening and not telling. You should classify bloggers into two easy groups, journal and journalist, when drawing up your lists. One thing that worked was holding an exclusive and casual event which was experiential and educational – in the good old days we used to call it a booze up ;-))
3 March, 2009 at 7:30 pm
Sparing a thought for daddy bloggers lol x
16 March, 2009 at 7:05 am
[...] Mummy Bloggers vs. Mommy Bloggers "Of course, they’ll try a granola bar or a DVD for the kids or a candle. Why not? People like free stuff! I assumed this thought process would work for the UK as well. Yeah, not so much… But not necessarily because they don’t like free stuff. It really comes down to a the fundamental differences in Mommies and Mummies" Originally from the US, Mel Seasons, blogger at London firm, Online Fire talks about the difference between US and UK maternal bloggers (see what I did there?) (tags: pneo001 blogs mommyblogging) [...]
16 March, 2009 at 8:58 am
Another thing to bear in mind is that parents here are a lot more paranoid – in my opinion and from anecdotal/first hand experience – about contents of freebies.
I did an event with lots of kiddie freebies last year and while the adults would pop anything into their mouth, the minute it was suggested for junior, the contents were a lot more closely looked at.
17 March, 2009 at 10:41 am
I can see how UK moms would be less willing to buy into PR promotions. I feel like US moms are both more aware of their influence on companies and more willing to take advantage of the freebies out there. I agree with Robin Grant that engaging online communities would probably be the more effective approach.
17 May, 2009 at 4:25 am
I found this: http://versuswiki.com/w/index.php/Mummy_vs_mommy – it’s got some info on the words Mummy vs. Mommy.
16 July, 2009 at 12:17 am
[...] written a few Mommy/Mummy posts before, and I know some of my Mommy Bloggers back from the States still read this, so [...]